Amid 'Jacindamania,' Kiwi businesses' pessimism may hurt growth

Amid 'Jacindamania,' Kiwi businesses' pessimism may hurt growth

Business confidence is at its lowest in seven years

Jacinda Ardern

Jacinda Ardern

Credit: Labour

New Zealand's youngest-ever prime minister, Jacinda Ardern, has seen her popularity soar at home and abroad, but now must deal with a growing economic problem as gloomy business confidence heads in the opposite direction.

Companies say measures such as a five per cent increase in the minimum wage, a looming ban on foreign homebuyers and lingering red tape around immigration in the midst of a skills shortage are increasing costs and forcing delays to investment.

Business confidence is at its lowest in seven years, and has been in free-fall since Ardern won elections in September - a stark contrast to the steady sentiment in Australia.

The risk, economists say, is that the mood affects investment plans and, ultimately, economic growth.

"There's been a raft of legislative changes that have moved so rapidly," said Adam Cunningham, the director of Village Accommodation, a chain of hotels and hostels. "The message is pretty disconcerting and demotivating."

Cunningham said he would have to raise prices and slow hiring to cover $850,000 in extra labour costs over the next few years.

The Labour-led government raised the minimum wage to $16.50 from $15.75 per hour in April and plans to increase it to $20 by 2021, which Westpac Bank estimates would raise nationwide labour costs by one per cent.

"That's a lot of money and I don't think there's anyone out there that thinks we've got that hidden in our back pocket," Cunningham said.

New Zealand's Treasury forecasts the economy will average about three per cent annual growth for the next few years, expanding as much as 3.8 per cent in the year ending June 2019 - the economy grew 2.9 per cent in 2017.

But many economists point out that if investment tapers off, so will growth.

The New Zealand Institute of Economic Research, which produces the business confidence survey, expects 2.5 per cent growth this year, while ANZ and Westpac Banks peg growth at 2.6 per cent and 2.8 per cent respectively.

The business community's outlook contrasts with the approval ratings of 37-year-old Ardern, whose rapid political rise to end a decade of centre-right National Party rule was dubbed "Jacindamania" across social media.

Ardern, who gave birth to her first child in June, has a net positive performance rating hovering just below 60 per cent, up from around 40 per cent during the election. It is the highest rating of a leader from either party in the last four years.

Many of Ardern's plans affecting businesses are the fulfilment of a campaign vow to "make the economy work for all New Zealanders" and curb rising inequality.

Little of the country's recent economic boom has trickled through to workers; wage growth has remained sluggish despite soaring housing costs.

"There's a moral issue where if you're working full-time you should be able to support yourself and your family," said Richard Wagstaff, the president of the Council of Trade Unions, which supports wage increases. "We’re looking to right that balance."

The government is also facing growing turbulence as negotiations with public workers increasingly lead to strikes.

Nurses are planning a work stoppage this week for the first time in 30 years after rejecting an $520 million offer that included pay increases.

More than 4,000 public officials from the Inland Revenue Department and Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment held a two-hour strike on Monday, and the union representing teachers says primary school educators are planning a strike in August.

Filtering through

Signs are emerging that businesses' pessimism is filtering through to actual investment plans and expected profits, which could hamper growth.

Just two per cent of companies surveyed in the quarter that ended in June said they planned investments, down from 17 per cent at the start of the year, according to data from the New Zealand Institute of Economic Research.

Merv Avery, the head of farm equipment dealer TransAg, said he was struggling to move more than a million dollars' worth of machinery, which he took out a loan to cover.

One problem, he said, was that farmers held off on buying items like tractors as they anticipated costly pollution regulations from Ardern's Labour Party and its support partner, the Green Party.

"We're stuck with $1.5 million and repaying interest," he said.

Even in the construction sector, which looked set for a windfall - Ardern's hallmark policy was to increase the housing supply - there are grumbles because of delays in permits and a construction worker visas.

"I'm trying to go overseas to bring people over and I can't do that until I've got more certainty," said Kevin Everett, the Auckland-based director of Building Recruitment, which sources workers from Britain, South Africa and the Philippines.

Some analysts, such as ASB Bank economists, predicted a central bank rate increase would be pushed from August to November next year and say a cut cannot be ruled out.

To be sure, an independent Parliamentary analysis has shown that business confidence sunk under the previous Labour government despite robust growth.

Economists said the concern, then was that gloomy sentiment would manifest as a "self-fulfilling prophecy" for companies.

"They may put off investment decisions … they spend less, and then that filters through to lower GDP," said Jeremy Couchman, senior economist at Kiwibank.

(Reporting by Charlotte Greenfield; Editing by Marius Zaharia and Gerry Doyle)

Follow Us

Join the newsletter!


Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.

Tags labourJacinda Ardern

Brand Post



Channel gathers for Nextgen New Zealand's Summer (Somewhere) Party

Channel gathers for Nextgen New Zealand's Summer (Somewhere) Party

Held in Auckland, Nextgen New Zealand's Summer (Somewhere) Party was an opportunity for celebration with a tangerine taste of summer. Nexgen's channel community seized the opportunity to catch-up with familiar faces and enjoy an in-person gathering.

Channel gathers for Nextgen New Zealand's Summer (Somewhere) Party
Show Comments