Menu
Class action alleges Dick Smith inflated value by $150M

Class action alleges Dick Smith inflated value by $150M

Second class action creeps towards court

One of two class actions being launched against Dick Smith Holdings is set to allege that the failed electronics and IT retailer inflated the combined value of its assets and equity by about $150 million, after tax.

The class action is set to be brought against the entity remaining following the retailer’s collapse early last year -- now under the control of receivers, Ferrier Hodgson -- by Johnson Winter & Slattery in partnership with Investor Claim Partner (ICP).

In an overview of the proposed claim against Dick Smith Holdings (DSH), which is set to be launched on behalf of former shareholders in the once publicly-listed company, Johnson Winter & Slattery said that the action will allege DSH made misleading and deceptive statements about its financial standing.

Specifically, the action will allege that DSH omitted information that investors and their professional advisers would “reasonably require to make a properly informed assessment of DSH’s assets and liabilities, financial position, performance and future performance”.

The law firm also said it will allege that DSH engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct and breached its continuous disclosure obligations by making representations and omitting to disclose information.

This, according to Johnson Winter & Slattery, meant that investors allegedly did not have all the information that a “reasonable person would expect to have a material effect on the price of DSH’s shares from the date of the prospectus to the date DSH went into administration”.

The theory that underlies class actions like this one is that the market price of shares is “inflated” due to non-disclosure or misstatement of material information. Accordingly, investors and the market at large value the shares on incorrect or incomplete information.

In this respect, the proposed class action claim will allege that the market price of DSH shares was inflated by reason of the non-disclosure of the Information by DSH, and that the failure to disclose this information caused losses to be suffered by shareholders who purchased shares at the inflated price through the prospectus.

According to Johnson Winter & Slattery, the information in the prospectus alleged to be misleading and deceptive, or omitted information considered material to the value of DSH shares, includes data associated with the company’s assets and liabilities.

In this respect, it is alleged that Dick Smith’s inventory directly after the date of the company’s acquisition by Anchorage was valued at about $102.5 million greater than it was valued by Woolworths, representing an upwards valuation of 49 per cent, with the revaluation of assets by Anchorage being the result of the creation of an undisclosed inventory “provision” of about $58 million.

According to the law firm, this provision was allegedly able to be written down over time, thereby enhancing future reported earnings. Further, the prospectus allegedly failed to disclose the provision or the extent to which inventory revalued upwards upon its acquisition.

As such, it is alleged that the Dick Smith prospectus falsely claimed that between the acquisition and the release of the public listing prospectus, there had been a significant reduction in DSH’s level of obsolete stock.

Broadly, the law firm alleges that DSH inflated the value of its assets and equity by about $150 million, after tax. 

Read more on the next page... 


Follow Us

Join the newsletter!

Or

Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.

Tags retaillegaldick smithlaw

Featured

Slideshows

Leading female front runners of the Kiwi ICT industry honoured at 2019 WIICTA

Leading female front runners of the Kiwi ICT industry honoured at 2019 WIICTA

Reseller News has honoured the leading female front runners of the New Zealand ICT industry at the 2019 Women in ICT Awards (WIICTA) in Auckland. The awards recognised standout individuals across six categories, spanning Entrepreneur, Rising Star, Shining Star, Community, Technical and Achievement. Photos by Gino Demeer.

Leading female front runners of the Kiwi ICT industry honoured at 2019 WIICTA
Reseller News kicks off awards season in 2019 with Judges' Lunch

Reseller News kicks off awards season in 2019 with Judges' Lunch

The 2019 Reseller News Innovation Awards has kicked off with the Judges Lunch in Auckland with 70 judges in the voting panel. The awards will reflect the changing dynamics of the channel, recognising excellence across customer value and innovation - spanning start-ups, partners, distributors and vendors. Photos by Christine Wong.

Reseller News kicks off awards season in 2019 with Judges' Lunch
Reseller News welcomes industry figures for 2019 Hall of Fame lunch

Reseller News welcomes industry figures for 2019 Hall of Fame lunch

Reseller News welcomed 2018 inductees - Chris Simpson, Kendra Ross and Phill Patton - to the third running of the Reseller News Hall of Fame lunch, held at the French Cafe in Auckland. The inductees discussed the changing landscape of the technology industry in New Zealand, while outlining ways to attract a new breed of players to the ecosystem. Photos by Gino Demeer.

Reseller News welcomes industry figures for 2019 Hall of Fame lunch
Show Comments