Menu
Oracle cries foul over expert in Java case against Google

Oracle cries foul over expert in Java case against Google

If it prevails, a trial may not happen until 2020

The accusations have been flying for five years now in Oracle's bitter legal battle with Google, and on Thursday the companies reportedly appeared in a San Francisco District Court to hear Oracle argue its latest charge: that the expert brought in by the federal judge presiding over the case is biased in Google's favor and should be disqualified.

James Kearl, a professor at Brigham Young University, was asked to serve as an expert on the case by Judge William Alsup for an unbiased view of the facts.

The facts in question, of course, are those surrounding Google's use of Oracle's Java code in the development of its wildly successful Android mobile platform. Oracle charges copyright infringement, and the courts have flip-flopped over the years in their decisions. The Supreme Court rejected the case in June.

In the meantime, however, Kearl has also served in the ongoing Apple v. Samsung patent lawsuit, and his position there is the source of Oracle's current discontent.

"When he was hired by Samsung in Apple v. Samsung, he sided with Google in a highly publicized case where the patents at issue involved technology that is part of Android," Oracle charged in a motion filed Oct. 15. "One of the issues in that case was whether, as Apple argued, Samsung used Dr. Kearl’s analysis to give the jury a low damages number in an attempt to make all patents appear to have little value."

In short, "it is no longer appropriate for Dr. Kearl to serve as a neutral expert in this case," Oracle said, adding that no replacement expert is needed now that the question of patents -- originally considered a factor but since eliminated -- is no longer part of the equation.

"The parties’ experts in the normal adversary process will sufficiently present the issues to the Court and the jury," Oracle said.

Google has rebuffed Oracle's claims.

"Oracle’s motion mischaracterizes the Court’s stated reasons for appointing Dr. Kearl, wrongly downplays the tremendous complexity of the copyright damages analysis on retrial, and falls back on innuendo to accuse Dr. Kearl of being a partisan for Google and Android," it said in a response filed Oct. 29. "There is no reason whatsoever to think Dr. Kearl will favor Google."

In a separate declaration of his own filed Oct. 28, Kearl supported Google's assertions. He also was in court on Thursday.

Neither Google nor Kearl responded to a request for comment. Oracle declined to comment.

In the hearing on Thursday, Judge Alsup reportedly warned that disqualifying Kearl could delay the case considerably. "If I agreed with you and knocked out Dr. Kearl, we would delay this case 18 months while we found another expert," Alsup is said to have told Oracle's attorney. The trial could be delayed as far as 2020, he reportedly suggested.

In August, Oracle accused Google of "destroying" the market for Java.

Currently, a jury trial is scheduled for May 2016. Damages sought by Oracle are expected to amount to as much as $1 billion.

"The impartiality of judges and experts appointed by judges is a bedrock principle," said Ray Van Dyke, a patent and technology attorney, via e-mail. "Bias of any sort is anathema to the judicial system, and this potential for bias allows challenges, such as here."

If a particular expert becomes known as a "hired gun" for an industry, then "a charge of bias is tenable," Van Dyke added. "If, however, the expert has no track history and is propounding reasonable interpretations, then bias cannot be assumed."


Follow Us

Join the newsletter!

Or

Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.

Tags Google

Brand Post

What to expect from your IT Distributor

Whether you’re just starting out or you’ve been around since before the dot com rollercoaster, choosing the right distribution partner can be a pivotal factor in your success. This definitive guide outlines the traits that every IT partner needs to look for in their IT Distributor.

Featured

Slideshows

Meet the Reseller News 30 Under 30 Tech Awards 2020 winners

Meet the Reseller News 30 Under 30 Tech Awards 2020 winners

This year’s Reseller News 30 Under 30 Tech Awards were held as an integral part of the first entirely virtual Emerging Leaders​ forum, an annual event dedicated to identifying, educating and showcasing the New Zealand technology market’s rising stars. The 30 Under 30 Tech Awards 2020 recognised the outstanding achievements and business excellence of 30 talented individuals​, across both young leaders and those just starting out. In this slideshow, Reseller News honours this year's winners and captures their thoughts about how their ideas of leadership have changed over time.​

Meet the Reseller News 30 Under 30 Tech Awards 2020 winners
Reseller News Exchange Auckland: Beyond the myths — how partners can master cloud security

Reseller News Exchange Auckland: Beyond the myths — how partners can master cloud security

This exclusive Reseller News Exchange event in Auckland explored the challenges facing the partner community on the cloud security frontier, as well as market trends, customer priorities and how the channel can capitalise on the opportunities available. In association with Arrow, Bitdefender, Exclusive Networks, Fortinet and Palo Alto Networks. Photos by Gino Demeer.

Reseller News Exchange Auckland: Beyond the myths — how partners can master cloud security
Reseller News welcomes industry figures at 2020 Hall of Fame lunch

Reseller News welcomes industry figures at 2020 Hall of Fame lunch

Reseller News welcomed 2019 inductees - Leanne Buer, Ross Jenkins and Terry Dunn - to the fourth running of the Reseller News Hall of Fame lunch, held at the French Cafe in Auckland. The inductees discussed the changing face of the IT channel ecosystem in New Zealand and what it means to be a Reseller News Hall of Fame inductee. Photos by Gino Demeer.

Reseller News welcomes industry figures at 2020 Hall of Fame lunch
Show Comments