Menu
Big tech companies back Samsung in Apple patent fight

Big tech companies back Samsung in Apple patent fight

Samsung is whittling away at a four-year-old $1B damages award, and has asked the court to cut another $399M

Law books

Law books

Tech companies including Google, Hewlett-Packard, Dell and Facebook are backing Samsung Electronics as it appeals a court ruling to pay Apple almost US$1 billion in damages in a patent infringement suit.

Samsung has already persuaded the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit to whittle the bill down to $548 million, but in June asked it to cut another $399 million. Apple, however, is not giving up, and on Monday filed a 24-page document asking the court to deny Samsung's request.

Meanwhile, though, Google and others had filed a friend of the court brief arguing that upholding the ruling "will have significant detrimental consequences for the continued development of useful modern technologies." The brief, filed July 1, was discovered by InsideSources on Monday.

The case dates back to a lawsuit filed by Apple in 2011, alleging that Samsung phones infringed on several iPhone patents. A U.S. court eventually awarded Apple damages of $930 million after a jury found that Samsung infringed its design and utility patents and diluted the trade dress, the overall look and packaging of a product. Samsung appealed the judgement and in May, a panel of three judges on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit shaved off $382 million in damages related to trade dress dilution, as the panel disagreed with the jury, leaving $548 million in damages awarded for the design and utility patent infringements.

Samsung then asked for a full bench review of part of the court's ruling relating to $399 million of the damages, its entire profits from products found to infringe three Apple design patents relating to a portion of the iPhone's outer shell and one graphical-user-interface screen, saying that the damages should be limited to its profits from the infringing features.

The companies backing Samsung's call for a rehearing noted in their brief that the appeals court panel concluded that the relevant statute "explicitly authorizes the award of total profit from the article of manufacture bearing the patented design" and that the smartphone was a single "article of manufacture" because the "innards of Samsung's smartphones were not sold separately from their shells as distinct articles of manufacture to ordinary purchasers."

That decision, they said, "will lead to absurd results and have a devastating impact on companies who spend billions of dollars annually on research and development for complex technologies and their components."

It could for instance allow the owner of the design patent to take all profit from an infringing product, even if buyers didn't care about the infringing element and bought the product for its many other features, they said.

Apple defended its claim to all the profit from the offending devices, saying that after Samsung copied its design, its share of the smartphone market jumped from five percent to 20 percent in two years, while Apple's market share fell, bringing Samsung billions of dollars in revenue and profit from its infringing products.

This case is the last big legal fight between Apple and Samsung, which agreed last August to drop all patent lawsuits between them outside the U.S.

Loek is Amsterdam Correspondent and covers online privacy, intellectual property, online payment issues as well as EU technology policy and regulation for the IDG News Service. Follow him on Twitter at @loekessers or email tips and comments to loek_essers@idg.com


Follow Us

Join the newsletter!

Or

Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.

Tags GoogleFacebookApplelegalDellHewlett-Packardsamsungintellectual propertypatent

Featured

Slideshows

Meet the leading female front runners of the Kiwi channel

Meet the leading female front runners of the Kiwi channel

Reseller News honoured the leading female front runners of the New Zealand channel at the 2018 Women in ICT Awards (WIICTA) in Auckland. The awards honoured standout individuals across seven categories, spanning Entrepreneur; Innovation; Rising Star; Shining Star; Community; Technical and Achievement.

Meet the leading female front runners of the Kiwi channel
Meet the top performing customer-centric Microsoft channel partners

Meet the top performing customer-centric Microsoft channel partners

Microsoft honoured leading partners across the channel following a year of customer innovation and market growth in New Zealand. The 2018 Microsoft Partner Awards recognised excellence within the context of the end-user, spanning a host of emerging and established providers.

Meet the top performing customer-centric Microsoft channel partners
Reseller News launches new-look Awards at 2018 Judges’ Lunch

Reseller News launches new-look Awards at 2018 Judges’ Lunch

Introducing the Reseller News Innovation Awards, launched to the channel at the 2018 Judges’ Lunch in Auckland. With more than 70 judges now part of the voting panel, the new-look awards will reflect the changing dynamics of the channel, recognising excellence across customer value and innovation - spanning start-ups, partners, distributors and vendors.

Reseller News launches new-look Awards at 2018 Judges’ Lunch
Show Comments