Menu
No reduced tax rate for e-books, top EU court rules

No reduced tax rate for e-books, top EU court rules

Value-added tax on e-books must be charged at the full rate, not the reduced rate for paper books, the CJEU ruled

E-books must be subject to the full rate of value-added tax (VAT), and European Union countries may not extend tax exemptions for books to include e-books, the EU's highest court ruled Thursday, adding that it considers downloadable e-books to be services.

Most EU member states, with the exception of Bulgaria and Denmark, impose a lower rate of VAT on physical books than on other products and services. The lower rate for books is one of a limited number of exemptions allowed under the EU's VAT Directive.

In January 2012, France lowered the VAT rate on e-books to 5.5 percent, and Luxembourg to 3 percent, matching the rates they levied on paper books. The European Commission asked the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) to rule that the move breached the VAT Directive.

The directive only allows reduced VAT to be applied to books on a physical medium, so the case turned on what the court considered to be a physical medium.

Last year, the CJEU ruled that reduced-rate VAT may be charged on e-books sold on a CD or USB stick, as those are physical mediums.

However, while an e-book delivered over the Internet requires a physical support such as a smartphone, e-reader or computer in order to read it, this support is not included in the scope of the law, the Court ruled Thursday.

Moreover, it found that the VAT Directive excludes any possibility of a reduced VAT rate being applied to "electronically supplied services," adding that the supply of e-books by download or web streaming is such a service.

France and Luxembourg must now comply with the Court's judgement as quickly as possible, raising the VAT on e-books to the countries' full VAT rates of 20 percent and 17 percent, respectively.

The only way to reduce the VAT rate on e-books sold over the Internet would be for the European Commission to propose a change in the law, a spokesman for the court said.

The Commission is planning just that -- but not before next year, said its taxation and customs spokeswoman Vanessa Mock.

"The Commission appreciates that member states may want to define their own priorities, including on culture policy, in their taxation policy. This should be done within the EU legal framework. This is why the Commission will address this matter through the extensive overhaul of the VAT system which is currently being prepared. We hope to be able to communicate on this next year," she said.

Loek is Amsterdam Correspondent and covers online privacy, intellectual property, online payment issues as well as EU technology policy and regulation for the IDG News Service. Follow him on Twitter at @loekessers or email tips and comments to loek_essers@idg.com


Follow Us

Join the newsletter!

Error: Please check your email address.

Tags european commissionCivil lawsuitslegalCourt of Justice of the European Union

Featured

Slideshows

A snapshot of the Kiwi partners set to shine at the Reseller News Awards

A snapshot of the Kiwi partners set to shine at the Reseller News Awards

With the 2017 Reseller News ICT Industry Awards only weeks away, Reseller News profiles the power line-up of partners set to dominate the biggest night on the channel calendar. ​Ranging from the enterprise, down through the mid-market and small business sectors into the heart of the start-up scene, the end result is the most diverse and wide-ranging partner line-up in the history of the Awards, playing host to the leading innovators of the past 12 months.​

A snapshot of the Kiwi partners set to shine at the Reseller News Awards
Channel celebrates as HP marks 50 years in NZ

Channel celebrates as HP marks 50 years in NZ

HP marked 50 years in New Zealand at an event in the vendor's Auckland's headquarters last night, with a host of key channel figures coming along to celebrate. Photos by HP.

Channel celebrates as HP marks 50 years in NZ
Show Comments