Menu
Last week in Apple v. Samsung: a 'holy war' for $US2 billion

Last week in Apple v. Samsung: a 'holy war' for $US2 billion

The trial began with Apple asking for $2 billion and executives taking the court behind the scenes of iPhone development

Samsung attorney John Quinn holds a smartphone as he makes his opening statement in the San Jose federal courthouse on April 1, 2014

Samsung attorney John Quinn holds a smartphone as he makes his opening statement in the San Jose federal courthouse on April 1, 2014

Apple and Samsung were back in San Jose federal court last week arguing over more patents and another set of devices. Apple is demanding more than $US2 billion in damages, in the second case between the companies in California.

Jury selection began on Monday with roughly 130 prospective jurors, who were whittled down to 10 people. Many are iPhone and iPad users and just one has a Samsung smartphone, but many have Samsung TVs.

The trial got off to a rocky start Tuesday with two of the 10 jurors dropping out -- one due to sickness and the other hardship. But the trial can continue with fewer, and the lawyers got down to business with their opening statements. Highlights that day included Apple's damages demand, which hadn't been made public before, and the disclosure of several internal Apple and Samsung documents.

Perhaps the spiciest was a 2010 email from Steve Jobs that listed "Holy War against Google" among the agenda items for a management retreat. Apple marketing chief Phil Schiller later said that wasn't the theme for the meeting, only a note from Jobs to presenters.

The Samsung documents revealed something of the crisis that appears to have gripped the company when the iPhone went on sale.

"If you compare the UX (user interface) with the iPhone, it's a difference between heaven and earth," read one Samsung email from February 2010.

Apple documents showed it was also worrying about Samsung. One email, from Jobs, warned that Apple "is in danger of hanging on to the old paradigm too long" if it didn't innovate.

The first day-and-a-half of the trial was probably the most interesting for the jury, with Phil Schiller and Apple engineer Greg Christie taking them on an inside journey through the development and launch of the iPhone.

The court took two days off, then came Friday afternoon -- the moment when the talk, inevitably, turned to the drier topic of the patents themselves. Apple's first expert, computer scientist Andrew Cockburn, claimed, not surprisingly, that Samsung's phones had infringed on Apple's patents. Cockburn disclosed at the beginning of his testimony that he's being paid NZ$575 (US$494) per hour for his work.

Quotes of the week

"The total damages are high, but I hope you understand the reason the damages are high is because the scope of Samsung's infringement is massive." -- Apple attorney Harold McElhinny

"They put that number out there, in your heads, so that is the damages horizon you are thinking of. It's a gross, gross exaggeration and an insult to your intelligence." -- Samsung attorney John Quinn, reacting to Apple's demand

"You're going to hear Samsung point the finger at Google, but don't be misled about that. This case is not about Google." -- Apple's McElhinny in his opening statement to the jury

"It's an attack on Android. That's what this case is about. It's about Apple trying to limit consumer choice and gain an advantage over its competitors." -- Samsung's Quinn during his opening statement

"We wondered what could come after the iPod. We wanted to try and invent that future rather than let it happen to us." -- Apple marketing chief Phil Schiller, recalling Apple's work developing the iPhone

"It was astonishing. We knew for at least one day we were a huge success and it had hopefully all been worth it." -- Greg Christie on how he felt on the day the iPhone went on sale

What's next?

Apple will continue building its case with testimony from experts. Among those expected next week are Thomas Deniau, an Apple software engineer; Todd Mowry, a professor in Carnegie Mellon's computer science department; and Alex Snoeren, a professor of computer science and engineering at the University of California, San Diego.

The case will resume Monday morning and is scheduled to continue Tuesday and Friday next week, and those three days every week, through to late April. Jury deliberations are expected to begin immediately after the lawyers finish presenting their case.

Martyn Williams covers mobile telecoms, Silicon Valley and general technology breaking news for The IDG News Service. Follow Martyn on Twitter at @martyn_williams. Martyn's e-mail address is martyn_williams@idg.com


Follow Us

Join the newsletter!

Or

Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.

Tags smartphonesAppleAndroidlegaliPhoneconsumer electronicsintellectual propertypatentSamsung Electronics

Featured

Slideshows

Channel gathers to celebrate the Reseller News Innovation Awards 2020 winners

Channel gathers to celebrate the Reseller News Innovation Awards 2020 winners

More than 500 channel leaders gathered in Auckland on 21 October at the ​Reseller News Innovation Awards ​2020 to celebrate the achievements of the New Zealand technology industry's top partners, start-ups, vendors, distributors and individuals.

Channel gathers to celebrate the Reseller News Innovation Awards 2020 winners
Meet the winners of the 2020 Reseller News Innovation Awards

Meet the winners of the 2020 Reseller News Innovation Awards

Reseller News honoured the standout players of the New Zealand channel in front of more than 500 technology leaders in Auckland on 21 October, recognising the achievements of top partners, start-ups, vendors, distributors and individuals.

Meet the winners of the 2020 Reseller News Innovation Awards
Meet the Reseller News 30 Under 30 Tech Awards 2020 winners

Meet the Reseller News 30 Under 30 Tech Awards 2020 winners

This year’s Reseller News 30 Under 30 Tech Awards were held as an integral part of the first entirely virtual Emerging Leaders​ forum, an annual event dedicated to identifying, educating and showcasing the New Zealand technology market’s rising stars. The 30 Under 30 Tech Awards 2020 recognised the outstanding achievements and business excellence of 30 talented individuals​, across both young leaders and those just starting out. In this slideshow, Reseller News honours this year's winners and captures their thoughts about how their ideas of leadership have changed over time.​

Meet the Reseller News 30 Under 30 Tech Awards 2020 winners
Show Comments