Menu
Trade group opposes proposal to make websites liable for user comments

Trade group opposes proposal to make websites liable for user comments

A request by state attorneys general to change the Communications Decency Act is a bad idea, NetChoice says

A proposal to make websites liable when user-generated comments violate state laws would be disaster for many popular online destinations, according to e-commerce trade group NetChoice.

A proposal by state attorneys general group the National Association of Attorneys General (NAAG) to amend the Communications Decency Act would open up popular sites like Facebook, Yelp and Reddit to criminal prosecution of state laws, including libel and defamation laws, NetChoice said Thursday in its periodic release of its Internet Advocates Watchlist of Ugly Laws (iAWFUL) list.

The proposed change in Section 230 -- the safe harbor provision -- of the 1996 Communications Decency Act would remove legal protections for websites from state prosecutions for comments site users make. It's possible, NetChoice said, that websites could then face criminal prosecution for "archaic" defamation laws, including a Georgia law prohibits speech that "blackened the memory" of a state native or a Louisiana law that prohibits showing "contempt" for a resident.

"That liability protection unleashed the development of sites like Facebook, Reddit, WordPress and many others that enable user-generated content," NetChoice said in a blog post earlier this month. "The whole Web 2.0 revolution was premised on innovators being allowed to provide technical platforms without fear that they would be held legally responsible for all of the words and actions of anyone using their platforms."

The NAAG proposal, advanced at the group's June meeting, would remove website protection for user comments violating any state criminal law, said Steve DelBianco, NetChoice's executive director. Across the U.S., there are about 27,000 local sheriffs who can enforce state libel laws, he said by email.

"There's a good chance one of these sheriffs will want to defend a local restaurant or inn from a scathing review posted on Yelp, and the [NAAG] amendment would allow Yelp to be liable for someone else's review," he said.

A NAAG spokeswoman declined to comment on NetChoice's iAWFUL list, but Attorney General Marty Jackley of South Dakota said in June that the current wording of Section 230 has "essentially given these guys immunity" when state criminal laws are broken.

Not all state officials are in favor of changing the law. North Dakota State Representative Blair Thoreson, a Fargo Republican leading a multistate task force on technology issues, has distributed a resolution opposing the proposed change.

Grant Gross covers technology and telecom policy in the U.S. government for The IDG News Service. Follow Grant on Twitter at GrantGross. Grant's email address is grant_gross@idg.com.


Follow Us

Join the newsletter!

Error: Please check your email address.

Tags governmentinternetFacebooklegislationsocial networkinge-commerceNetChoicereddityelpInternet-based applications and servicesSteve DelBiancoNational Association of Attorneys GeneralMarty JackleyBlair Thoreson

Featured

Slideshows

Kiwi channel closes 2017 with After Hours

Kiwi channel closes 2017 with After Hours

The channel in New Zealand came together to celebrate the close of 2017, as the final After Hours played out in front of a bumper Auckland crowd.

Kiwi channel closes 2017 with After Hours
Meet the top performing HP partners in NZ

Meet the top performing HP partners in NZ

HP honoured leading partners across the channel at the Partner Awards 2017 in New Zealand, recognising excellence across the entire print and personal systems portfolio.

Meet the top performing HP partners in NZ
Tech industry comes together as Lexel celebrates turning 30

Tech industry comes together as Lexel celebrates turning 30

Leading figures within the technology industry across New Zealand came together to celebrate 30 years of success for Lexel Systems, at a milestone birthday occasion at St Matthews in the City.‚Äč

Tech industry comes together as Lexel celebrates turning 30
Show Comments