Menu
Oracle, SAP battle it out in court dispute

Oracle, SAP battle it out in court dispute

Software maintenance -- who provides it and at what price -- is at the heart of the corporate theft lawsuit Oracle filed against arch-rival SAP, one expert said.

Oracle charges SAP, its SAP America division and its Tomorrownow subsidiary with stealing thousands of software products and confidential materials from Oracle. In the suit, filed in the U.S. Federal District Court in the Northern District of California, Oracle said the case is about "corporate theft on a grand scale."

But there's probably more to it than that. "This is totally about third-party maintenance," said Ray Wang, principal analyst at Forrester Research. "If Oracle wins, this decimates the third-party maintenance market."

SAP's Tomorrownow subsidiary provides support services to users of Oracle software. Tomorrownow requires access to certain Oracle technology in order to serve its customers. Oracle appears to be taking issue with the way that Tommorrownow acquires that information, Wang said.

Both SAP and Oracle are involved in delivering third-party maintenance services. Through a partnership with Systime, a subsidiary of CMS Computers, Oracle offers some maintenance for users of certain SAP products. However, SAP has been more successful moving Oracle customers onto its maintenance plans than Oracle has doing the reverse, Wang said.

SAP and Oracle have a long and bitter competitive history, but the current market environment is leading their rivalry into a particularly aggressive stage, which could also be driving this most recent dispute. Large corporations often replace or upgrade their software systems on a seven to ten year cycle. Because many of them bought new platforms in preparation for Y2K, they may be starting to investigate upgrades. In addition, Oracle recently refreshed its full product line and so is particularly keen to win new sales. It's unclear yet how the lawsuit itself may play out.

Jeff Norman, a partner in the IP practice of Kirkland & Ellis LLP, Chicago, said it appears there is a lot of "smoke" in Oracle's complaints, but that doesn't mean there's a fire. Still, if the company could prove that "this was theft of their copyrighted software and trade secrets, it's a pretty serious claim," he said.

Norman said because SAP is a foreign company, it could also be prosecuted by the U.S. Department of Justice for criminal espionage, which would be even more damaging for SAP. "The Justice Department takes these claims very seriously," he said.

Without access to the evidence in the complaint, Norman describes two potential scenarios. One is that TomorrowNow used information from Oracle to offer services to customers whose contracts with Oracle precluded them from using third-party services. The other, and more serious claim, is that TomorrowNow stole trade secrets and intellectual property from Oracle not to serve customers that can legitimately receive service from the SAP subsidiary, but so SAP can compete with Oracle.

Though the claims "look bad" for SAP, Norman said he finds it "hard to believe" SAP would commit such crimes. "SAP is a big company and fairly conservative; I would find it surprising if that were going on," he said.

Denis Pombriant, managing principal of Beagle Research, in Stoughton, Massachusetts, also thinks it's unlikely top-level SAP management had anything to do with the alleged actions by Tomorrownow. However, with the relationship between Oracle and SAP as contentious as it is, "nothing would surprise me," he said.

If SAP did want to obtain proprietary Oracle materials for nefarious purposes, doing it through TomorrowNow would be "an ideal front," Pombriant said.

"They could blame Tomorrownow for the problem if they got caught," he said. "There is plausible deniability here."

Pombriant added that the decision in the case probably will come down to "motive and whether or not it could be proven there was an attempt [by SAP] to cause harm."

China Martens in Boston contributed to this report.


Follow Us

Join the newsletter!

Or

Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.

Tags OracleSAP

Events

Featured

Slideshows

Meet the Reseller News 30 Under 30 Tech Awards 2020 winners

Meet the Reseller News 30 Under 30 Tech Awards 2020 winners

This year’s Reseller News 30 Under 30 Tech Awards were held as an integral part of the first entirely virtual Emerging Leaders​ forum, an annual event dedicated to identifying, educating and showcasing the New Zealand technology market’s rising stars. The 30 Under 30 Tech Awards 2020 recognised the outstanding achievements and business excellence of 30 talented individuals​, across both young leaders and those just starting out. In this slideshow, Reseller News honours this year's winners and captures their thoughts about how their ideas of leadership have changed over time.​

Meet the Reseller News 30 Under 30 Tech Awards 2020 winners
Reseller News Exchange Auckland: Beyond the myths — how partners can master cloud security

Reseller News Exchange Auckland: Beyond the myths — how partners can master cloud security

This exclusive Reseller News Exchange event in Auckland explored the challenges facing the partner community on the cloud security frontier, as well as market trends, customer priorities and how the channel can capitalise on the opportunities available. In association with Arrow, Bitdefender, Exclusive Networks, Fortinet and Palo Alto Networks. Photos by Gino Demeer.

Reseller News Exchange Auckland: Beyond the myths — how partners can master cloud security
Reseller News welcomes industry figures at 2020 Hall of Fame lunch

Reseller News welcomes industry figures at 2020 Hall of Fame lunch

Reseller News welcomed 2019 inductees - Leanne Buer, Ross Jenkins and Terry Dunn - to the fourth running of the Reseller News Hall of Fame lunch, held at the French Cafe in Auckland. The inductees discussed the changing face of the IT channel ecosystem in New Zealand and what it means to be a Reseller News Hall of Fame inductee. Photos by Gino Demeer.

Reseller News welcomes industry figures at 2020 Hall of Fame lunch
Show Comments