Menu
Samsung, Apple patent dispute heads for retrial on damages

Samsung, Apple patent dispute heads for retrial on damages

Judge Lucy H. Koh in California has proposed a jury retrial in March or April next year

A patent dispute between Apple and Samsung Electronics in a California court is headed for a retrial next year, after an appeals court vacated and sent back to the lower court for further proceedings a part of the damages award by a jury.

The retrial with eight jurors is now scheduled for March or April next year, Judge Lucy H. Koh of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, San Jose division proposed Tuesday.

The judge indicated that she was acting on the mandate just received from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. The lawsuit has dragged in the district court since 2011 alongside another suit also for patent infringement.

"The instant retrial on damages will be the parties’ fourth jury trial before this Court, third jury trial in the instant case, and second damages retrial in the instant case," Koh wrote in a case management order.

The court had awarded Apple damages of US$930 million after a jury found that Samsung infringed Apple’s design and utility patents and diluted its trade dresses, which refer to the overall look and packaging of a product.

But on appeal, the Federal Circuit reversed the jury’s findings that the asserted trade dresses are protectable, and vacated the damages relating to trade dress dilution on certain products.

The appeals court decision impacted $382 million in damages and the new trial will now reassess the damages payable by Samsung for the patent infringements by five of its earlier products: the Fascinate, Galaxy S4G, Galaxy S Showcase, Mesmerize and Vibrant.

Judge Koh is trying to ensure that the trial does not deviate from its focus, stating that she will not allow substitution of damages experts unless in extraordinary circumstances, permit supplemental fact discovery, or let the parties expand the scope of the damages retrial. Koh has set aside seven days for the retrial, giving each side fixed time slots for opening statements, closing arguments and evidence.

The judge has, however, indicated that she may hear a separate motion from Apple which wants the court to order Samsung to pay $548 million in damages. These are damages relating to infringement of design and utility patents that were not vacated by the appeals court, which instead asked the district court to go ahead with a final judgment on this part of the damages.

Samsung is asking the court to declare invalid the claim of an Apple patent also known as the pinch-to-zoom patent, which figured in the lawsuit, or to stay proceedings.

The South Korean company points to a decision in December by the Patent Trial and Appeal Board of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office that found claims of the Apple patent invalid, according to Samsung's filing. Judge Koh has allowed one filing from each company on the matter.

She also seems to be encouraging the companies to come to a settlement  in the long-standing case. Referring to a case management conference this month, Judge Koh wrote that "the parties shall also address whether they are willing to engage in alternative dispute resolution, and if so, what form, with whom, and when."

Follow Us

Join the New Zealand Reseller News newsletter!

Error: Please check your email address.

Featured

Slideshows

Examining the changing job scene in the Kiwi channel

Examining the changing job scene in the Kiwi channel

Typically, the New Year brings new opportunities for personnel within the Kiwi channel. 2017 started no differently, with a host of appointments, departures and reshuffles across vendor, distributor and reseller businesses. As a result, the job scene across New Zealand has changed - here’s a run down of who is working where in the year ahead…

Examining the changing job scene in the Kiwi channel
​What are the top 10 tech trends for New Zealand in 2017?

​What are the top 10 tech trends for New Zealand in 2017?

Digital Transformation (DX) has been a critical topic for business over the last few years and IDC is now predicting a step change as DX reaches macroeconomic levels. By 2020 a DX economy will emerge and it will become the core of what New Zealand industries focus on. From the board level through to the C-Suite, Kiwi organisations must be prepared to think and act digital when the DX economy emerges in 2017.

​What are the top 10 tech trends for New Zealand in 2017?
Top 15 Kiwi tech storylines to follow in 2017

Top 15 Kiwi tech storylines to follow in 2017

​The New Year brings the usual new round of humdrum technology predictions, glaringly general, unashamedly safe and perpetually predictable. But while the industry no longer sees value in “cloud is now the norm” type projections, value can be found in following developments of the year previous, analysing behaviours and patterns to formulate a plan for the 12 months ahead. Consequently, here’s the top Kiwi tech storylines to follow in 2017...

Top 15 Kiwi tech storylines to follow in 2017
Show Comments