Menu
Judge not sold on $324M settlement in Silicon Valley tech worker case

Judge not sold on $324M settlement in Silicon Valley tech worker case

The suit accuses companies like Apple and Google of conspiring not to hire each others' workers

A proposed US$324.5 million settlement of claims that Silicon Valley companies including Google and Apple suppressed worker wages by agreeing not to hire each others' employees may not be high enough, a judge signaled on Thursday.

Judge Lucy Koh said in court that she was worried about whether that amount was fair to the roughly 64,000 technology workers represented in the case. "I have concerns over whether it's sufficient," she said, speaking at the U.S. District Court in San Jose, California.

Koh didn't say whether she would approve the settlement. Throughout the course of Thursday's hearing, she questioned not just the amount but the logic behind the settlement as presented by lawyers for both the plaintiffs and the defendants.

Google, Apple, Adobe and Intel agreed to a settlement in April of charges that executives at those companies had entered into secret agreements not to hire or "poach" employees from each other, in order to protect their investments. Plaintiffs, many of whom are engineers, argued those agreements restricted their mobility and drove down wages.

A big chunk of the evidence in the case relies on emails sent between high-profile executives, including the late Apple CEO Steve Jobs and Google co-founder Sergey Brin.

"If you hire a single one of these people, that means war," Jobs told Brin at one point, according to a court filing.

Judge Koh, and some attorneys familiar with the case, said exchanges like that were strong evidence against the accused companies.

But attorneys for the plaintiffs said on Thursday they had doubts about whether jurors would see those emails as convincing evidence, citing studies they had done.

Koh was dubious. "I think [jurors] would have found these documents very significant and compelling," she said, referring to both the emails and other evidence, such as oral agreements and confidential compensation information that allegedly was shared between the companies.

Previously named defendants Intuit, Lucasfilm and Pixar have already settled in the case, for about $20 million.

Robert Van Nest, an attorney for Google, said Thursday that roughly 8 percent of the plaintiffs were represented in that earlier settlement. At that rate of compensation, the proposed settlement for the remaining companies would be lower than $324.5 million, he said.

"This number is right in the sweet spot of what is not only fair, but a premium over that settlement," he said.

But Koh questioned whether it makes sense to compare the previously named defendants to Adobe, Apple, Google and Intel.

It's unclear what the judge will decide, or when. The next hearing in the case is set for November.

Zach Miners covers social networking, search and general technology news for IDG News Service. Follow Zach on Twitter at @zachminers. Zach's e-mail address is zach_miners@idg.com

Follow Us

Join the New Zealand Reseller News newsletter!

Error: Please check your email address.

Tags business issuesInternet-based applications and servicesantitrustAdobe Systemssocial networkingfinancial resultssocial mediaintelinternetInternet service providersAppleGooglelegal

Featured

Slideshows

Examining the changing job scene in the Kiwi channel

Examining the changing job scene in the Kiwi channel

Typically, the New Year brings new opportunities for personnel within the Kiwi channel. 2017 started no differently, with a host of appointments, departures and reshuffles across vendor, distributor and reseller businesses. As a result, the job scene across New Zealand has changed - here’s a run down of who is working where in the year ahead…

Examining the changing job scene in the Kiwi channel
​What are the top 10 tech trends for New Zealand in 2017?

​What are the top 10 tech trends for New Zealand in 2017?

Digital Transformation (DX) has been a critical topic for business over the last few years and IDC is now predicting a step change as DX reaches macroeconomic levels. By 2020 a DX economy will emerge and it will become the core of what New Zealand industries focus on. From the board level through to the C-Suite, Kiwi organisations must be prepared to think and act digital when the DX economy emerges in 2017.

​What are the top 10 tech trends for New Zealand in 2017?
Top 15 Kiwi tech storylines to follow in 2017

Top 15 Kiwi tech storylines to follow in 2017

​The New Year brings the usual new round of humdrum technology predictions, glaringly general, unashamedly safe and perpetually predictable. But while the industry no longer sees value in “cloud is now the norm” type projections, value can be found in following developments of the year previous, analysing behaviours and patterns to formulate a plan for the 12 months ahead. Consequently, here’s the top Kiwi tech storylines to follow in 2017...

Top 15 Kiwi tech storylines to follow in 2017
Show Comments