Menu
German court rules Apple photo-management patent invalid because of Steve Jobs keynote

German court rules Apple photo-management patent invalid because of Steve Jobs keynote

He demonstrated the technology before Apple tried to get a patent for it in Europe

Germany's Federal Patent Court invalidated an Apple photo-management patent because Steve Jobs showed how the technology worked during a keynote months before the company applied for the patent in Europe.

The Munich-based court invalidated the Apple patent Thursday, said court spokeswoman Ariane Mittenberger-Huber in an email Friday. The validity of the patent was contested by the German subsidiary's of both Google-owned Motorola Mobility and Samsung Electronics.

The patent, which covers the bounce-back effect in a photo gallery, was partly annulled because the relevant priority date of the application was June 2007, after Jobs demonstrated the technology on stage in January 2007 during the first iPhone keynote, she wrote.

The main part of the patent was declared invalid because of prior art, she said. Prior art is typically documentary evidence that ideas or designs for which patent protection is sought are not original.

"As a matter of principles even an inventor's own public demos can be held against his own patents if they took place before the filing of an application," said Mittenberger-Huber.

Apple probably forgot an important difference between U.S. patent law that was in effect at the time and the patent laws in Europe, wrote Florian Mueller, a legal consultant who has been an adviser for tech companies including Oracle and Microsoft, and participated in oral proceedings in Germany. In 2007, U.S. patent applicants had a 12-month grace period in which what they made public about their technology would not constitute prior art, Mueller wrote on his blog.

Europe, however, never had such a grace period, said Kevin Mooney, a U.K.-based intellectual property lawyer who specializes in patent litigation, in an email.

"This historical difference between U.S. and European patent law has been well known for many years and has provided many opportunities to invalidate patents in Europe based upon premature articles, presentations etc. in the U.S.," he wrote, adding that this is "basic knowledge for patent lawyers."

"What is surprising is that Apple did not take suitable precautions as most sophisticated companies, being aware of the risk, usually have strict guidelines to avoid premature disclosure," Mooney said.

While the patent was rendered invalid in Germany, it has been successfully used in Europe. In 2011, for instance, a Dutch court granted Apple an E.U.-wide sales ban on the Galaxy S, SII and Ace based on the same patent. Apple also won an injunction against Motorola Mobility in the regional court of Munich in 2012.

Apple can still appeal the case within a month after the formal notification of the judgment to the Supreme Court, Mittenberger-Huber said.

Apple and Google declined to comment. Samsung and Motorola did not respond to a request for comment.

Follow Us

Join the New Zealand Reseller News newsletter!

Error: Please check your email address.

Tags telecommunicationapplicationsiospatentSamsung ElectronicslegalMobile OSesMotorola MobilitymobileAppleAndroid OSintellectual property

Slideshows

Top 50 defining moments of the New Zealand channel in 2016

Top 50 defining moments of the New Zealand channel in 2016

Reseller News looks back on a tumultuous 12 months for the New Zealand channel, assessing the fallout from a year of sizeable industry change. Whether it be local or global mergers and acquisitions, distribution deals or job changes, the channel that started the year differs somewhat to the one set to finish it - Reseller News assesses the key moments that made 2016.​

Top 50 defining moments of the New Zealand channel in 2016
​Hewlett Packard Enterprise honours high achieving NZ channel

​Hewlett Packard Enterprise honours high achieving NZ channel

Hewlett Packard Enterprise honoured its top performing Kiwi partners at the second running of its HPE Partner Awards in New Zealand, held at a glitzy ceremony in Auckland. Recognising excellence across eight categories - from distributors to resellers - the tech giant celebrated its first year as a standalone company, following its official split from HP in 2015.

​Hewlett Packard Enterprise honours high achieving NZ channel
Nutanix treats channel partners to Christmas cruise

Nutanix treats channel partners to Christmas cruise

Nutanix recently took to the seas for a Christmas Cruise around Sydney Harbour with its Australia and New Zealand staff, customers and partners to celebrate a stellar year for the vendor. With the sun out, they were all smiles and mingled over drinks and food.

Nutanix treats channel partners to Christmas cruise
Show Comments